[TLDR (too long didn’t read): If you are reading this, chances are this has aroused your interest. This Reader is about how the working class lacks political parties that truly defend their HR interests and about what explains the lack of political will of the ruling class; it hints at a way to overcome this impasse. For a quick overview, just read the bolded text]. Traducir/traduire los/les Readers; usar/utiliser deepl.com
Climates of the political kind
–The current situation around the world leads many to believe that today’s political climate will soon become so tense that the ideological conflict will spill over onto the streets. (Juan P. Cardenas)
—Revolutions start in the imagination, and that is the one thing the fascists (or AI) can not take away from us. …Not yet, anyway. (Gil Duran)
1. The working class is completely abandoned; it lacks parties that genuinely represent it. Workers have fallen for the electoral charade and are subject to an institutional climate of control and not-so-veiled repression by the powerful.* The task remains the same: to build power from the working-class grassroots, as this is the only way to change the oppressive climate and structurally improve their conditions. To continue hoping that the parties of the old system will do something does, not only reveal naivete or ignorance, but also reveals an attitude of resignation in the face of a model that rages against anything that is even vaguely reminiscent of fulfilling and protecting fundamental human rights (HR). (Luis Mesina) “Ours are lost causes. The bad guys won”. (Louis Casado) But no evil lasts a hundred years, nor will people tolerate it.
*: …and repression is not acknowledged, much less felt by the powerful wealthy classes. (Isabel Allende, My Name Is Emilia del Valle)
The absence of a stern political will in the parties that purportedly represent the working class leads to a chronic failure to make meaningful commitments
2. Political will is commonly used to mean a greater resolve (not a commitment!) on the part of states (or in our case political parties). But ‘having the political will’ is not the prerogative of each politician, who usually act only in response to consistent and compelling pressure from its cronies from the Right or, more rarely, from organized and mobilized claim holders from the Left. Therefore, mostly, it is not an individual lack of political will, but rather an imposition-of-a-political-will-by-the-powerful to oppose or stall the implementation of progressive policies that tackle, among other, HR abuses. We cannot forget that a political will ‘must be pulled’ from those in power and thus depends on the capacity of local, national, and transnational public interest civil society and social movements to demand from governments and international actors for them to uphold the HR framework. A lack of political will is a function of how lopsided the concentration of power is.
So, what is meant by the often touted ‘lack-of-political-will’? How can we deconstruct it?
3. In the case of HR, it is not a lack of political will, but rather the accumulation-of-a-political-will-by-the-powerful to oppose or stall the implementation of progressive policies that tackle HR abuses. I repeat that a political will for HR must be pulled from those in power —and not pushed by those in power.
4. Bottom line here, political will and commitment do not come from the sky. (Abhay Shukla) Both have–to and do permeate from society through proactive lobbying or demanding. But also be aware: Provided a given political will is exercised and leads to the carrying out of specific HR obligations by the state, there still remains a problem: Too often, this political will is exerted top-down when what is needed is bottom-up planning, implementation and accountability with claim holders’ inputs.
5. Being aware that political will is changeable/renewable/or reversible by the whims of politics (Al Gore), is a reminder for HR activists that they must not give up ‘pulling’.
6. Campaigns in this direction by claim holders must thus be brought into an effective rainbow coalition. Synergy makes their movement bigger than the sum of their parts. (United Edge) Human rights activism, now in patches, must be brought into a single quilt. (Greg Smith, Nicholas Freudenberg)
All of which brings me to another aspect of the prevailing political climate…
The problem with liberalism in politics is that it rests on a fundamental contradiction that cannot be resolved
–Politics without ideas stimulates corruption. (Revista Primera Piedra)
7. Liberalism has always and will always fail in exercising a consistent and determined ‘pro-HR will’. It will always be ‘wishy-washy’ (promoting a social-democratic lukewarm revolution?) and this explains everything about our current HR moment. A rhetorical militancy is simply not enough.
8. Liberals try to hold two commitments at once
—on the one hand, they are firmly committed to Capitalism. [But there is a problem with this commitment: Capital accumulation requires cheapening labor and natural extraction. This eventually comes into direct conflict with principles of the second commitment like HR and equality. And whenever this conflict appears, the liberal ruling class sides with Capital, abandoning their lofty principles and pushing workers and nature ‘under the carpet’. Every. Single. Time].
—on the other hand, as you guessed, they express mostly lip-service support for principles like HR, democracy, equality, freedom of speech, the environment and the rule of law. This duality is the core of liberalism. [Because it is unacceptable that values accommodate to circumstances, some of many a politician’s rhetoric seems inspired by my grandmother’s bedtime stories, whose endings I never heard, because I usually fell asleep halfway through…]. (Mukesh Kapila)
9. This duality further results in flagrant displays of hypocrisy. These liberals run for office on nice-sounding platforms, but end up either betraying their promises or actively working against their stated values. They will slash public services, bail out banks, imprison journalists, beat up students, expand fracking, overthrow democratically elected leaders in countries rendered poor, bomb liberation movements, fund a genocide(!) –and they will even trash international law itself– anything that is needed to maintain the conditions for capital accumulation.
10. At most, they may try to negotiate mediocre compromises**: a few social policies here and there, some abortion rights, a tiny increase in the minimum wage, but nothing that will pose any serious threat to capital accumulation. Thus the soul-crushing slowness of liberal incrementalism. Ultimately, they are unwilling to take any of the obvious steps that would actually resolve our urgent social and ecological crises.
**: Beware: a) Minimal HR improvements are designed to distract us from the big picture. b) The enemies of liberals are not so much their ideological opponents as much as ‘the enemy within their duality’.
11. This is why nobody trusts liberal politicians anymore. This is why they come across as so fantastically insincere, and even sneering. This is why they feel so spineless and ‘empty’. The center cannot hold. Liberalism will always collapse, inevitably handing power to fascists –and this is not acceptable.***
***: “Liberalism claims that all ideas are respected. But fascism does not. Fascism is not an idea. It is the death of all ideas.” (Sandro Pertini, President of Italy, 1978–1985)].
Bottom line
12. The rather tortuous trajectories of liberalism that have brought us this far, have come to an end. From here on out, a profound liberation of the commons on this tiny blue planet is imperative. Whether this occurs before or after a war****: will determine the difference between a paradigmatic transition for the living and a revolutionary project for the survivors.
****: Capitalism brings on war just as a cloud brings on a storm. (Jean Jaures)
13. There is only one way to overcome this deadly impasse, and that is to mobilize a socialist alternative. We need a political movement that can unite the working-classes, overcome Capitalism, deliver real economic democracy and enable us to achieve rapid progress toward social and ecological goals.***** (Jason Hickel)
*****: They may cut all the flowers, but they will not be able to stop spring (Pablo Neruda). No winter lasts forever; no spring skips its turn. (Hal Borland, American writer, journalist and naturalist (1900-1978)
Claudio Schuftan, Ho Chi Minh City
Your comments are welcome at schuftan@gmail.com
#HumanRightsReaders
#HumanRights
#ClaudioSchuftan
Postscript/Marginalia
-On the facetious side: In politics as in matrimony there is nothing unconditional. (I. Allende)
-Recognition for politicians committed to social causes generally comes too late, because among us it is easier to lay flowers for the dead than to bestow the laurels of glory upon the living. [When they ask us about him/her, we will not say s/he died. Like the old Romans did, we will say s/he lived. (Albino Gomez).
