Human Rights: Food for a modest breakthrough thought ‘Three HR-relevant topics’
HRR 844
[TLDR (too long didn’t read): If you are reading this, chances are this has aroused your interest. This Reader covers three intertwined HR-relevant topics: The criminalization of HR, has the HR cause progressed? and what it means to be free. For a quick overview, just read the bolded text]. Traducir/traduire los/les Readers; usar/utiliser deepl.com
Three intertwined human rights-relevant topics
A. The criminalization of human rights (Philip Alston)
—A focus on ‘atrocity crimes’ and on criminal behavior obscures the need to develop more complex and comprehensive human rights (HR) approaches.
1. The logic seems to be that, if the problem is not classified as a crime, it is not going to be taken seriously. An appropriate equilibrium must be established before it is too late. The prosecution of atrocity crimes is important, but so, too, is the need to adequately address other violations of HR and humanitarian law. Perhaps even more important is the need to move beyond an obsession with narrowly defined violations and also engage with structural issues such as extreme poverty, massive inequality and entrenched racially and sexually discriminatory governments and others’ behavior.
2. The first step is to acknowledge that there is a problem. Not just governments, but the HR community as a whole –in consultation with victims of HR violations broadly defined rather than survivors of dramatic atrocities– need to pause the rush to embrace criminal law–based solutions and instead identify a more balanced and effective set of other non-criminal HR priorities. International criminal law must be a part of that vision, but it should not be the tail that wags the dog. (P. Alston)
B. Human rights can record progress in the areas of respect, protect and fulfill
—But highlighting such progress often forgets or excludes pointing at what upstream causes and constraints were the ones that made progress necessary in the first place. (Simon Kieser)
3. Even long-sustained HR deadlocks are not necessarily permanent. Global conditions can and do change quickly so that those with very different agendas can and do still find ways to cooperate. Although full of compromises, evasions, and exclusions, UN covenants have formed the bedrock of the international HR system ever since their ratification. In 2026, an international consensus may be as distant as in 1966 when the covenant on economic, social and cultural rights (CESCR) was ratified.
4. However, history demonstrates that, under the right circumstances, progress in HR may only require a convergence of interests among actors (claim holders and duty bearers) even if pursuing their own objectives. Resolution of historical grievances does not necessarily need to take place before full agreements are reached. Human rights innovations can eventually mature, entrench themselves and expand beyond these grievances. (Raymond A. Smith)
How, then, should we understand progress in a period that feels defined less by breakthroughs and more by backlashes?
5. Take, for example, both the pessimistic narrative that the international HR framework has failed and the more optimistic impulse to double down on implementing it. Resistance often emerges when entrenched interests feel threatened. Even amid mounting pressure, organizations around the world have secured important gains in law and policy, norms and narratives, accountability and remedy, as well as prevention and protection. These advances –that have meant simultaneously holding the line against regression, breaking new ground in critical areas and laying the foundations for longer-term structural change– have defied conventional expectations of linear progress.
6. Examples of shoring-up the right to protest exist; they have defended hard-won legal guarantees and have ensured these guarantees protect those most at risk. Protests have also broken new ground, including holding corporations increasingly accountable for climate harms and securing recognition of tax abuse as a HR concern. And, not least, they have seeded longer-term societal shifts, from growing recognition of disability as a matter of justice to the increased prominence of ‘care’ as a framing for economic and social priorities. Many of these gains have been incremental, contested, and often the fruit of years of collective effort.
7. Strategies anchored in an active leadership, participation, and the lived experiences of those most affected by injustice, are also critical, because solutions become harder to reverse when those claiming their rights are recognized, not as victims, but as protagonists. The most consequential shifts in HR are not always visible or valued by the conventional measures of success we use. (Lesley Carson, Ignacio Saiz, Open Global Rights)
Let me now switch to the third topic relevant to HR.
C. What does it mean to be free in the abstract?
–A man who is content with what he is given, and does not ask for what he ought to ask-for, is a slave. (José Martí, Cuban national patriot, 1853–1895)
8. The freedom granted to us by liberalism is not accompanied by the conditions that allow those rendered poor to be truly free. Under these conditions, the more autonomous they are in-the-abstract to make decisions and life choices, the fewer opportunities they have to effectively exercise that autonomy and protect and fulfill their HR. When the freedom granted to the vast majority is the freedom to be miserable, we are faced with the misery of freedom. Choices are permitted within a menu determined by those who hold the power. These are, therefore, largely illusory freedoms.
9. In China, there are authorized freedoms and unauthorized freedoms, but the criterion is dictated by a political diktat, and not as a result of the principle of freedom taking precedence over the principle of equality. From this, we can conclude that, in terms of limitations on freedom, the differences are not as great as one might imagine. Ponder though that China is also experiencing a rise in social and economic inequality. Chinese ‘people’s democracy’ measure their performance by how effectively it improves the material living conditions of its citizens and ensures their long-term well-being. Consultation with the rank and file is constant. Without a formal liberal democracy, China appears to have found other means to listen to its citizens and ensure that their needs are met.
10. The USA-State–Inc., with its unmistakably dystopian character represents the ultimate distortion of liberal democracy in the way political power distances itself from citizens and their expectations of well-being and of dignified living conditions. To mitigate the political cost, the state invests in symbolic policies with populist and nationalist overtones.
11. Subjectively, citizens of either of these state forms have been ideologically conditioned to believe that the state experience they live-under is the only possible or legitimate one, no matter how much frustration it causes them. (Boaventura de Sousa Santos)
Claudio Schuftan, Ho Chi Minh City
Your comments are welcome at schuftan@gmail.com
All Readers are available at www.claudioschuftan.com
If you do not want to receive these Readers anymore, do send me a message with ‘unsubscribe’ in the subject line.
#HumanRightsReaders
#HumanRights
#ClaudioSchuftan
